Being the only expensive restaurant in Geneseo, I have gone here a few times for special occasions. I have quite enjoyed the fries with dipping sauce, bethia burger, salmon, swordfish, waffle fries, and home-made chips. This time I order the trio with French Onion Soup, Bean Salad, and half a Portobello Burger. The burger was so bad it was practically inedible. The bread was hard, and the “burger” dry. The bean salad was refreshing, but the onion soup mediocre. For lunch, I would stick with the American classics. Otherwise, their dinner options are much better.
Big Tree Inn
46 Main St
Geneseo, NY 14454
Phone: 585.243.5220
http://www.bigtreeinn.com/
I would say that, in general, the food here is really good, but what you ordered was disappointing.